| I Beat You | Mikkeller | American IPA | 9.8% |
| I Feel The Universe | Finback Brewery | Gose | 5.0% |
| I Hardcore You | Mikkeller | Imperial IPA | 9.5% |
| I Hate My Boss | Spiteful Brewing Company | American Stout | 6.5% |
| I Love Lamp | Evil Genius Beer Company | Hefeweizen | |
| I Love You With All of My Stout | Evil Twin | American Imperial Stout | 12.0% |
| I Love You With My Stout | Evil Twin | American Imperial Stout | 12.0% |
| I Milk Your Drinkshake | All In Brewing | American IPA | 6.0% |
| I Must Break You | Imperial Oak Brewing | Russian Imperial Stout | 10.0% |
| I See A Darkness (Bottle Conditioned w/ Emptiness Yeast) | Tired Hands | | 8.5% |
| I See a Tartness | Sante Adairius Rustic Ales | American Porter | 8.4% |
| I Think She Hung The Moon | Naughty Brewing Co. | | 8.6% |
| I Want My HTV | Odd Side Ales | Imperial IPA | 9.0% |
| I Want My HTV | Oddside Ales | Imperial IPA | 9.0% |
| I Want Smore | Tioga-Sequoia Brewing Company | American Stout | 7.2% |